The Framework Restored, the Debate Renewed

There are rules that govern how institutions respond to harm—rules that determine whether a voice is heard, whether evidence is weighed, whether a process is fair. When those rules change, the change is not merely technical. It reshapes the experience of everyone who enters the system, from the person who reports harm to the person accused of causing it.

The Trump administration has finalized a regulation restoring the 2020 Title IX rule governing how schools investigate and adjudicate sexual misconduct allegations. The rule, announced Monday by Education Secretary Linda McMahon, formally rescinds the Biden-era 2024 regulation and re-implements the framework established during the first Trump administration .

The 2020 rule requires colleges and universities to hold live hearings with cross-examination, allows representatives for both parties to call witnesses and challenge credibility, and permits schools to use a higher standard of proof in disciplinary proceedings. It also narrows the definition of sexual harassment for hostile-environment purposes .

The move comes after a federal court vacated the 2024 rule nationwide in January 2025, restoring the 2020 framework as the basis for enforcement. The Education Department has been enforcing the 2020 rule through guidance for nearly two years .

McMahon framed the change as clarity. "It just gives clarification to students, teachers, schools, parents—everyone now knows what the rule is and how everyone is going to abide by it," she told Fox News' "OutKick." She described it as "a full return to Title IX" .

The rule stops short of formally defining "sex" as biological sex, though the department's preamble highlights court decisions that struck down the 2024 rule over its protections for gender identity and sexual orientation .

The announcement drew swift criticism from advocacy groups. The Human Rights Campaign called the rule a move that "suppress[es] the voices of survivors of rape and sexual assault and make[s] it easier for their perpetrators to get away with their actions." The organization noted that the administration denied the public any opportunity to comment, with the rule taking effect the day after its announcement .

The National Women's Law Center warned that the rule "erodes protections for student survivors," arguing that the administration is "systematically weakening the very laws that keep students safe and schools accountable" .

The Education Department has also issued guidance emphasizing that schools must independently investigate allegations of sexual misconduct rather than relying solely on law enforcement referrals, and that collective bargaining agreements cannot interfere with Title IX investigations .

The rule takes effect immediately. Legal challenges are expected, given the administration's decision to bypass the notice-and-comment process typically required for such regulatory changes .

---

AI Image Disclaimer: The images accompanying this article are AI-generated and do not depict the actual individuals or institutions referenced.

Sources: Politico, Human Rights Campaign, National Women's Law Center, McGuireWoods