Four weeks could have made a difference; the Premier said no

There is a particular irony in being asked to respect a process, being told your concerns will be taken under advisement, and then watching that process be upended days later. In British Columbia, municipal leaders gathered at their annual convention in mid-September and passed an emergency resolution asking provincial party leaders to respect the principle of separate election periods. Premier David Eby appeared at the convention on September 18 and said his government would take the resolution under advisement. Four days later, he called a snap provincial election . Sometimes the most telling moments in politics are not the announcements themselves, but the gap between what was promised and what followed.

Cori Ramsay, the former president of the Union of British Columbia Municipalities, described the decision as a "party foul" that could have waited four weeks. She said the chief election officer in Prince George, where she is running for council, is "pulling his hair out" because workers hired for the local election are rescinding their contracts for better-paying provincial election jobs . "Saddened to learn local election workers are hopping over to the provincial election and leaving municipalities in the lurch," Ramsay posted on social media .

The timing is the crux of the problem. British Columbia's municipal elections are scheduled for October 17. The provincial election's advanced voting period runs from October 16 to October 21, meaning the two elections overlap directly . Ramsay said municipalities will be left scrambling to find and train staff, and she anticipates long lines and frustration on October 17 when voters face not one but two election lineups. "It's going to run the risk that people are not going to line up twice," she said .

The competition extends beyond paid staff. Ramsay said volunteers who would normally support municipal candidates have already switched over to provincial candidates. Media outlets, especially in smaller communities, will also be hard-pressed to cover both elections, she said, adding that "the election coverage is going to suffer" . Other municipal leaders, including Vancouver Mayor Ken Sim, have also criticized the early election call .

Premier Eby has defended his decision, saying there is never a wrong time to ask British Columbians for input about the direction of the province amid tariff threats from U.S. President Donald Trump . When Ramsay asked the Premier at the UBCM convention why the election could not wait four weeks, she said she received no satisfactory answer. "It's a rude behaviour, a social mistake," she said of the timing. "I don't know that it can be called anything other than a party foul" .

The consequences of this overlap will unfold over the coming weeks. Municipalities will train replacement staff. Voters will navigate two ballots, two campaigns, and two sets of issues competing for their attention. Whether the Premier's calculation proves correct—that the province needs a mandate now—will be answered at the polls. What is already clear is that the decision has left a mark on the relationship between the provincial government and the local leaders who asked, in good faith, for a little more time.

Former UBCM president Cori Ramsay calls B.C.'s snap election a "party foul" that could have waited four weeks. The provincial election's advanced voting overlaps with municipal elections on October 17, causing staff shortages and competition for volunteers. Premier Eby cited tariff threats as the reason for the early call.

AI Image Disclaimer: Visuals in this article are produced by artificial intelligence for illustrative purposes only.

Sources: The Canadian Press, Vancouver Island CTV News, Times Colonist, Parksville Qualicum Beach News, The Province