Between belief and sight, a testimony that unsettled the room.

There are testimonies that settle a room, and there are testimonies that unsettle it. On Thursday, at the coroner's inquest into the death of Regis Korchinski-Paquet, Claudette Beals offered the second kind. Speaking about the afternoon of May 27, 2020, when her daughter fell from a twenty-fourth-floor balcony while police were in the apartment, Beals said something that had not been said before in the proceedings: she saw officers push her daughter toward the balcony .

The moment was brief and enormous. Inquest counsel Roger Shallow asked Beals to distinguish between what she believed and what she saw. "I saw them pushing Regis towards the balcony," she said. "That's all I saw, but I saw that myself" . The statement prompted lawyers for the officers at the scene to raise concerns that their clients had not been given a chance to respond to the allegation when they testified earlier in the week. The presiding coroner, Dr. David Cameron, called a recess, and the inquest was later adjourned until Friday morning .

The officers who arrived first at the apartment, Const. Shane Beaudoin and then-Const. Adam Vandenbrink, had testified that Korchinski-Paquet moved quickly to the balcony after being asked to speak with a paramedic. They said she had been allowed into the apartment to use the bathroom . Their accounts described a young woman in crisis, not a person being physically directed. Beals's testimony introduced a different account, one that had not been disclosed to the other parties before the inquest began .

The context of that day is part of the record now. Korchinski-Paquet, twenty-nine, had epilepsy and had experienced two seizures earlier in the day. A neurologist who reviewed her records but did not treat her testified that she showed symptoms consistent with postictal delirium, an altered mental state that can follow seizures . Police had been called over a disturbance involving knives. Her family had told dispatchers about her condition. The officers testified they had limited information about her epilepsy when they arrived .

The inquest's scope is not to assign legal responsibility but to examine what happened and to issue recommendations that might prevent similar deaths. Dr. Cameron reminded jurors of that mandate when the proceedings resumed, saying the inquest had done well in exploring the intersection of epilepsy, postictal delirium, and police encounters, and that it would continue to do so "in the name of fairness and transparency" . A police watchdog had previously cleared the officers of wrongdoing, finding that Korchinski-Paquet fell as she tried to move from her balcony to a neighbor's .

For the family, the inquest is one of the few remaining forums in which to be heard. Korchinski-Paquet was an Afro-Indigenous woman whose death came amid a global reckoning over policing and race, and her case became a symbol for many of the questions that reckoning raised. But at its center is a mother who lost a daughter and who, on Thursday, told a room full of lawyers and jurors what she remembered seeing. The legal process will determine how that memory fits into the larger record. It cannot determine what it meant to the person who lived it.

The inquest continues Friday. The lawyers will work through the procedural questions raised by Beals's testimony, and the jury will eventually hear more evidence and craft its recommendations. What remains, beyond the process, is the image Beals carried with her for six years and finally spoke aloud: a moment she says she saw, offered into a record that had not yet held it.

---

Image Disclaimer: All images in this article are AI-generated and are not photographs of the individuals or events described.

Sources: CBC News, Toronto Star, CP24, CHCH